GRRRR! Scanner advice
16 years ago
The machine I'm using to scan my stuff is an Epson Scanner/Copier/Printer threeway I got, I think, in 2002. It is, I believe, on its little electronic deathbed. The copy and print functions have long since failed, no matter how often I clean or attempt to troubleshoot it by the manual directions, but until just now the scanner still worked. The thing is, unless it has ink, it won't run the scanner, and it will automatically determine that the ink is out at a set time no matter how little ink in the cartridge has actually been used. (which is none, in this case, since the print/copy functions died more than a year ago. Does the stuff go bad?) The ink for it is both expensive and no longer carried in local stores.
I loathe the quick obsolescence of computer technology and cringe at the prospect of having to responsibly dispose of this hated boat-anchor of a once shiny and exciting device. But I'm not buying really expensive (like, $40+ a cartridge) ink for a broken machine that can no longer use it, but is just designed such that its tertiary function won't run without the stuff.
Perforce, I require a new scanner. Quickly, because I need to scan a commission with a Feb. 14th deadline, and since I am about to be really busy, I was hoping to get the finished art scanned tonight (inks) and tomorrow (finished painting). Thankfully, scanners are cheaper than I thought they were, for instance one on the best buy site for $150, which is about what I can afford for this acquisition. I plan to cruise for one tomorrow.
I am encouraging all of you to share your opinions on what to get, what to look for and what to avoid. Scanners: we all love to bitch, complain and hate on 'em, but it would be nice if I could actually get something that would kill my artwork somewhat less than the old clunker. Please help.
The notion "need cartridges to scan" is ridiculous. The notion "cartridges expire" is even worse. You should not pay the printer mafia for your right to scan.
I'd offer to sell you mine, but a) I live on the other side of the Pacific to you (so the freight would be a killer), and b) you'd need a new power pack for it as the voltage here is 220V, not 110V...
Personally, I’ve always favored HP. The old Scanjet software was great—it looked like hell, but it was simple and no-nonsense. Unfortunately the software that now comes with their consumer and prosumer scanners tries way too hard to be user-friendly. The first thing you want to do is open up the preferences and tools settings and turn off all the damned wizards. Still, the Scanjet 7400c I’ve got is great, and it’s several years old now.
I used to have a cheap consumer Canon scanner. It did an adequate job, but it and the software were so undistinguished I barely remember it, and don’t recall anything particularly good or bad.
If you can swing it, definitely get a prosumer model, whatever brand you choose. Consumer-grade scanners are cheap and flimsy, and their software tends to be rudimentary or obnoxiously helpful.
Five hundred seems like a lot . . . until you see the results.
All I can say in a positive manner, is -- buy a standalone scanner. Canons seem to be okay.
I don't have anything against the HP. I've just never used one.
the scanner didn't work too good, was slow and somewhat I missed many options to adjust the scan before importing it. also, a year later it died with a bang.
nowadays I use a HP deskjet 870, a three-in-one machine, which costed about as much as a scanner OR printer alone. there are aftermarket cartridges available which carry more ink, and the scanning quality is quite good.
I currently have three different scanners just laying about that I've acquired from neighbourhood front gardens. They usually work fine, and rain takes a while to penetrate their cases.
I'm in the UK though, and you could buy a couple of brand new scanners for the cost of shipping any one of these tubby beasties. One's big enough I'm gutting it and turning it into a light-box.
the problem also you will have is the grease. a scanner that old will require grease on the rails again to function well.
all in all you had best decide to get a new scanner. i got a cannon flat scanner for like $30 right from the store so it's not like they cost mega bucks and i scanned all my stuff up with it since 03-04.
i wish you well and a new scanner.
Cannon Canoscan LiDE 600f is the one I have. Compact and nice, scans directly into photoshop if I want it to. And I want it to.
As for getting rid of your older scanner: http://www.gazelle.com/