Wth porn ads??If they stay. I can't.
10 years ago
Petition to get porn ads off FA(hopefully they will listen): http://www.ipetitions.com/petition/.....move-adult-ads
Alright...so this is something that I'm not grabbing my pitchfork-jumping on the bandwagon-screaming to the sky.
It's actually something that I feel is a personal choice and a business one. A lot of artists have said it better and sport EXACTLY how I feel. But when it comes down to the nitty gritty: I cannot allow my artwork to be associated with a real-porn site. FA has always been something that I knew was risky to put my art on, but I always rationalized it:
1. FA is typically Sex positive and more importantly ALL ABOUT THE ART.
2. Up until now I could easily keep in my own little bubble on FA and not be associated with porn or porn artwork
3. NOT ALL MATURE ART SHOULD BE CONSIDERED PORN.
4. Keeping my art here(on an art-based furry site) shows my support for furries and the furry community. You could say it's kind of like a bumper-sticker saying: hey, these guys are cool. Dont listen to the news BS. I'm not ashamed of being a part of this community/culture.
I'm not a porn artist. I keep it SFW. I dont really like porn, in fact porn can be a trigger to some very dark thoughts that I don't want to get into. Really, ironically, Furries and FA have been one of the first sex-positive things I've ever been introduced to. These porn-ads are a constant reminder to something that I not only loathe, but brings up some very dark feelings that I've been trying hard to let go for a very long time. I also believe there is a distinct difference between fatasy based adult-themed things and commercial porn.
Yes I know you can have ad-block and not see them(I actually haven't seen a single porn pop-up since this has happened and i dont even have ad-block)
but that is not stopping others from coming to my page and seeing the porn pop-up. I understand that you shouldn't see the porn ads if you're SFW filter is on; HOWEVER as stated I do not consider all mature art to be porn and there are a few artists I watch that will do tasteful-nudity.
FA and the furry community has been a safe haven for me. This is the first place I've ever found friends and have been truly accepted, ever. This community pulled me out of very dark times and has been a constant support for me. This community Made my artwork what it is today, making me be a professional. I owe A LOT to the furry community as a whole, but it all started here. On this page. This is not a choice that I make lightly and I type these words with disappointment and hope that FA will listen to their community and make changes. FA has fucked up a lot, I know. But I had always hoped that it would eventually become better and maybe they would start listening. I'm still going to wait about a week before doing anything drastic. But if no changes happen I will be wiping my gallery and only posting here when I'm open for commissions elsewhere. I cannot afford to have a client outside the community, my family, or anyone else find my art here and get Rape/porn/bestiality ads. I've already started making the move away from furry artwork in general, but had made a promise to continue to take private furry-based commissions(some of my friends already know this) But the ads and the fact that I do not have a following outside of FA will most likely make it impossible. So if I leave. It will be mostly for good. But until then I'm going to stubbornly stay and hope that things will change.
Other artists who have said it better:
http://www.furaffinity.net/journal/6834771/
http://www.furaffinity.net/journal/6836142/
http://www.furaffinity.net/journal/6835581/
ALSO you can find me here: https://www.weasyl.com/~tidma if it comes down to it..weasyl will be my new main site for commissions/artsharing/etc
If you don't have it, install Greasemoney for Firefox https://addons.mozilla.org/en-US/fi...../greasemonkey/
or Tampermonkey for Chrome https://chrome.google.com/webstore/...../tampermonkey/
or Violentmoney for Opera https://addons.opera.com/en/extensi.....iolent-monkey/
Then, install this script to your addon: http://puu.sh/iATTl/459ba65294.js
the problem isn't that I can see the ads, but that others can.
I mean, let's be honest, the furry world does indeed mainly happen for porn, but there's a whole world beneath the surface. It's just that furries are more accepting towards that stuff in general, it's not a thing we live for. I've made more friends in this 'Porn' related fandom than in the real world, where pretty much everyone needs a small reason to just stab u in the back!
And really I think it's even a bit different from the aspect of a clean artist making it on this site.
I mean i never get asked to do porn and people are extremely respectful about sexuality in general. It is literally the very first place I've encountered this mentaility and has helped me get over some really horrid thoughts and grow as a person. Them doing this is literally instigating every negative News fed/youtube video/gross stereotype of furries they could muster and completely devaluing the good that is in this community.
Also I'm somewhat in the same boat. I haven't gotten a single porn ad and typically i keep my SFW filter off. I dont mind the third party ads, but this is something I personally can't tolerate for bother personal and business reasons.
I dont plan on abandoning you guys and if I do leave I will be making every possible way to make sure I can keep in touch
with that said I do have a weasyl and DA Both are under the name tidma
I just dont update them too often, but that may change.
I'm going to stubbornly cling to this account until FA has made it clear they aren't changing. All of this is with a very heavy heart :/
I want to get a career in art started so I've been posting art here to improve and get experience. I've begun to meet people that seem pretty cool as well. However, if my art is associated with porn, that's just a black mark, a complete nuke on it taking off.
Blocking ads doesn't change the fact that they're being actively supported by FA. Lots of people don't seem to use adblockers either.
My concern is that every time the staff made a fuckup, they've gotten away with it in the past every single time. Their experience says people will put up with it, who's to say it won't happen this time? Given the vast amount of porn in the fandom, are SFW artists being considered "acceptable losses?"
I have a lot of ill feelings towards the porn-industry, but pushing that aside, it's a bad career move to stay if they keep the ads. I've literally just started to move my career outside the community, but my artwork is very much associated with FA and if you type in "tidmatiger" "Tidma" or even my actual name you will get links to this gallery. I cannot trust that the SFW filter will work(as it hasn't from many peoples reports).
Now any child can visit FA and see nasty and 18+ things on every page.
It's down right disturbing. I've noticed over the past 3-4 years things like Icons and even adverts have gotten racier and racier. I dunno. I had/do genuinely hope that the site will improve..
And thats a little surprising that they booted your icon due to blood..sorry but any kid watching the discovery channel and seen lions eating have seen blood..
heh priorities. BLOOD NO. PORN A GO GO
the problem isn't that I can see the ads, but that others can. There have been many reports that the SFW filter/what you're viewing doesnt matter.
Otherwise thank you <3 I do like the fact that there are ways to block the in-general ads but not the art-sponsored FA ads
If it comes down to it though I'll most likely stop taking furry art commissions unless they are friends over skype period, unless they are at art conventions. I've been moving more into the professional world outside the fandom over the last year anyways. *shrugs* I can stay for the community, cons, etc. but i cant at this point easily take my business elsewhere. I just would rather not have to.
If i can/do get a good enough following on weasyl I'd be content.
If you can move into the pro scene, that's a good thing. I was thinking about that as a long term goal to chase... but I don't know, I just like to draw anthro (and horses) more than anything else. :P
it's definitely possibly and in some aspects there is defintiely still demand for anthro-type characters, they just might be more beast-like. But werewolves? yea..they will ALWAYS be a thing.
I mean magic the gathering has a surprisingly LARGE amount of "furry"type artwork
I...really like tribal shaman anthros personally.
i'm actually drawing a grey fox bone shaman right now for AC hahahahaha
I still have a long way to go. I only started taking drawing seriously some months ago, and what I do changes rapidly, I need to settle with a few styles first then I can try gathering the confidence to actually offer commissions. :3 ...and need to get a proper tablet because drawing on this Genius feels like going on the Dakar rally with a Smart. :D
gettinga good tablet is definitely a must for any digital artist though xD!the older wacoms are still pretty nice and you can get them fairly cheap on amazon or ebay :)
Anyone can be an artist they just have to take the time to gain the skills. Any shread of skill I have right now is because for the past 4-5 years I did literally(and still pretty much) do nothing but draw. I like to show people this: http://www.furaffinity.net/view/8746532/
because I feel it really shows what you can do if you push yourself really hard and really want to be an artist.
I just hope i can keep up the momentum xD
It's entirely unfair what's happening to everyone, and those responsible show no signs of remorse. I don't feel comfortable here either.
My sincerest best wishes to you, you deserve better.
Personally I use adblock since maybe a year back, but of course not everyone uses that. I just think that adult oriented ad banners only serve to make the page more unsightly and almost embarrasing. I have turned off ad block for this page at the moment just to see if I can see any of these ads. But I will probably sign that petition as I am against them in general.
I've been really trying to cling to this site as it's kinda a "home" in a way. I got started here, made friends here, and was able to make a business here. I love this community, but this is something I just can't ignore/nor can afford to.
I'd be taking a massive cut if i left as I have at most 200 followers on any other site. I'd rather FA change their minds and set things straight versus having to start over again.
Plus this really just adds to the bad stigma that furries already have. Anyone who is against furries can jump on FA now and point a finger at the horrid blatant porn ads and just go "SEE I TOLD YOU THEY ARE ABOUT NOTHING BUT PORN"
Again i'm really hoping they will back track...but I will also be steadily start becoming more common on weasyl. At this point i have ENOUGH of a following through email/twitter/skype/Cons that I can find business elsewhere. It just means i will no longer be offering commissions publicaly as often.
Really, hell. Can I just say some things a minute here? This is the first thing that is making me take a hard look at FA, IMVU, and their frickin' tragedy of handling those porn ads. And i'm only now realizing that this really affects me. And my ...not worldview, but FAview is rotating around. @_@
It would be REALLY SAD that only now i start watching your neat arts and suddenly you leave. But if I look at how people are going to look at us, INTO us, through the window of FA, then I start thinking maybe I might even leave too. That's sad. And it's stupid.
Those four points you put up I kinda also was about. ...What does it mean here, sex-positive?
...it'd be ad if you left furry creation as well-- maybe it's not best if an artist does only furry stuff, but you draw creatures really well and really fun, and it would suck to lose that. :/ I hope we can make a change to make FA ours again.
It is really sad. I was really against furries in the begining, fearing the stigma of nothing but porn and being associated with it. Now I'm invested into this community and love my friends and people that I've met here. These ads just renew that old fear and push some really negative stereotypes. I love meeting people here. I love and feel incredibly honored that people actually enjoy my art. Leaving here could/would mean loosing a lot of potential friends and the ability to create a bond with someone by helping their imagination come alive. I would be extremely sad to leave.
Also by sex-positive I mean that this is one of the only places That showed me: sex isn't an evil thing. That there is a very big difference between love, sex, and porn. That just because you are built differently sexually doesn't mean your wrong. You're body is beautiful and you shouldn't be afraid of it. The list just goes on and on. It's been a healthier mindset then what I had and literally has made me a better person in general.
...Actually, that's one of the biggest things anyone could point to in saying we're more than just about the sex. o.o
Ohhhh that's what sex-positive means then? AMMAGOSH THEN OH YEAH I'M ABOUT SEX-POSITIVE stuff. I mean sex-responsible and sex-regulate-yourself along with it but sex-positive yes, and I'm so squeeeing that you find something that great in this culture YAAAAAAY :D and... sex isn't an evil thing, wat. I think it's the excesses and letting it grab you and control you that is evil. c.c; that's scary.
hahahaah this comment could get suuuuuuper dark, but i really dont wanna go that route. Eitherway it stands. this community has made me feel good about myself and like myself and i personally hold it near and dear to the point that I will challenge people openly when they say something negative about the fandom.
The porn had originally kept me away and if thats what the site was about..I wouldn't be here.
"==Advertising Changes==
We've enabled mature third party ads on submissions which contain adult content. These ads will also show up on any page where adult content is visible (such as in a thumbnail). The system was recently updated to detect whether a page has general-rated content or contains adult material, and displays ads accordingly."
Truthfully until dragoneer makes a new update saying they will be removing the adult ads or at least clarifying what type of ads they will be using I cannot trust that they do not mean porn ads. I wouldn't mind cigars/sunglasses/cars/etc. I really don't care about that..that's kind of the nature of having a massive website like this. but porn? That degrades a lot of the furry community..
Read it like this: mature ads on Adult themed submissions.
I mean I mature anything that's bloody or gorey but that doesnt make it adult. idk.
If anything Dragoneer should at LEAST post an apology update regarding the porn ads. It's obviously offended a lot of people and this is one of those things that may actually push a lot of people out.
I hate that pretty much everyone is scattering :<
I was hoping that the IMVU thing would be a good thing meaning more order/better website/better admin response time/etc.
but if this is how they work..it's obvious they don't care about us..its just another money mongering scheme. It makes me really sad.
I hope they will be removed otherwise I think I'll delete all my sfw work here.
if there was some sort of mistake. eitherway if it was a fuck-up it's a really big one.
But... I could be wrong.
I'm not saying it doesn't piss me off knowing our FA is being contaminated with real pornography. Because it does.
the thing that gets me with it is where /when do you EVER seen porn advertisements? porn websites. It's the only place, Any other website blocks them. They literally have to allow mature/adult ads to be allowed on their facebook. I'm perfectly fine with 3rd party advertisements...Just not ones in adult nature.
And yeah, I suppose you're right. They should be able to turn off the pork ads then. And darn well should.
Saddly it also means they are doing a "do as I say not as I do" thing since its against the tos to post links to real porn.
Still thanks for letting us know about the petition and I'll make sure I watch you elsewhere just in case.
I'm already active and following you on Weasyl, so I'd be elated to see you update there more soon!
I don't want to see all of these artists and other individuals suddenly disperse and disappear where I won't be able to find them again because whether you like it or not, FA is a hub for this community. This is just a slap in the face for all of those that helped build this site into what it is now. FA would be nothing without the creators.
the whole thing makes me deeply sad.
It's like okay 3rd party ads for sunglasses, cars, whatever. I can deal with that it's not blatantly obtrusive and yea okay I can see it help funding the site, but porn? Where do they allow porn advertisements?Porn sites. thats its and I can't associate myself with a porn site.
And yes weather they change things or not I will be updating my weasyl more regularly and more often. I don't want to leave all together, but this has just been a series of events down to a path I really don't want to be on. :/
I'm with you. If the ads stay, I will take my business elsewhere.
I'm totally fine with some 3rd party ads, but tha just makes FA bother dangerous AND obnoxious. the hell
I really would love to keep up with you and your art, so please, let us know where you go! Also, I'm currently using Weasyl, and though it may be quiet, it's a much nicer site to use than FA, and probably will get busier as more poor decisions drag this site down into the gutter and it's demise. xD
I'm not even sure that my last point is a joke anymore.
Truthfully I'm here more for teh people and community. I love you guys. You're amazing and awesome! I haven't liked FA's administration for a veerrryyy long while.
I'll be definitely using more weasyl if i can help it. I don't have near the following..but I'm hoping more and more folks will go there as well. I like the fandom too much to completely disappear though xD
Right now I'm re-watching people on other sites.
And managing 3 galleries will be easier than 4.
Been watching your weasyl but il be dusting out my page^^ as well is checking on other places outside this community...
Pretty much doubt FA will last much longer to be honest at this point, dragoneers doosy this time may have well irreversibly cut off any way this site could still make money for imvu...
Then this? What the hell, this is bad. This isn't a porn site; it's a furry community. Sure there's a lot of porn drawings, but it's still not a -porn- site. Thus, this bull shit should not be shown on here...
For anyone interested in a good ad blocker so you don't have to see this bull shit, try out adblocker for Firefox or Chrome. It sadly blocks users' ads, but yeah...
Signed.
I've already got adblocker on chrome (DAMN YOU YOUTUBE ADVERTS)
but firefox and my antivirus automatically blocks the porn-o ads luckily.
The bottom line is we do not pay to use the site. Artists are generating a massive amount of combined revenue that would more than pay for the site but had made it clear a while back that paying FA a fee for selling their services was just not going to jive well, especially when SoFurry and Inkbunny, etc operate entirely for free. But they also do not have the amount of traffic this site does as you know and I think it escapes some people that this site runs in the tens of thousands of dollars a year to operate mostly due to that traffic. Bandwidth is anything but cheap. The domain name, servers, hosting services are all cheap in comparison on a high traffic site.
So... while I think ensuring the SWF option being selected is a better way to go about displaying adult ads at the end of the day this is not our website. Just because the furry community uses it doesn't mean it belongs to it. It could be unplugged today. Everyone will just migrate to another site just like what happened when Furnation and VCL collapsed. On that note, I appreciate you keeping galleries elsewhere too because while I may not share the same political view on porn as you do I do enjoy your artwork nonetheless and it's good to know that if you do end up feeling the need to close up shop here you can be followed elsewhere. For that I thank you.
Really I don't mind the advertisements at all. It's just I can't let a potential client/non-fur friend/family find my page here and see a flashing pron pop up, no matter the risk.
I often leave my SFW filter off mainly because not all mature work is pornographic in nature and because 99% of the folks I do watch dont do porn I know it shouldn't necessarily pop up in my feed. I have a few "mature" filtered art pieces but it's because of blood more then anything else. And tasteful nudity is definitely not adult in nature. The human body is a piece of art in its own right.
I do respect anyone who wants to stay or is comfortable with the porn pop ups. I just know it would be a future financially bad business move.
Out side of the business aspect I wouldn't be able stay for emotional health reasons. Porn is actually a really heavy trigger for me, but I also understand and know that, that is entirely my own problem that I have to deal with and it should never effect someone else views. I wont really comment on how I feel about porn in todays society other then my opinion is extremely negative and hateful towards it. I tried to keep that aspect out of my choice to actually leave the site as much as I can and make the logical choice and not the emotional one.
Also I'd never just up and leave. I owe you guys waayyyy too much to do that. this place started as a financial income and has turned into something that is very close to my heart. it'll be a lot harder to get rid of me then that xD
Really I was glad they started with the 3rd party ads, where they a little annoying? honestly not really, I viewed them as a necessary need to help fund a site that I've grown very fond of(or at least the community that harbors on it) and hoped that that would for the most part be the most of it. Websites like facebook, youtube, anywhere really all has 3rd party website advertising, however., the only site that has porn advertisments is(of my knowledge) a porn website..so if FA starts sporting porn advertisements that means thats what the people running it are viewing it as..and even if the tone it down...I dont like where this path is headed and simply dont want to be associated with it. If this was a hobby, fine sure whatever, but this is my career. If i only ever planned on working in the fandom i wouldn't care as much either, but i want to work for companies like Wizards of the coast, bethesda, etc. Furries dont give two shits about what people in the community sees it's what the people outside of the community see that the problem comes from. This is literally a slap in the face to anyone whose ever stated that the community is not just about pornography and sex.
And though the community doesnt pay the bills per say, if there is no community there is no site. Doesnt matter how popular a store is, if enough people have a bad experience its going to go out of business eventually. Same with FA. Really it's idiotic that IMVU bought this place assumed that porn ads would be a-okay and is litterally pissing off enough people that they could easily loose their investment. xD
You are right though. it's not my website so All I can do is shrug, be a little sad and walk away if it comes to it.
Otherwise Thank you for having a totally different opinion but still 100% respectful in your reply. I have been waiting ALLLLL day for the "QQ STUPID FURRY DRAMA BULLSHIT GO CRY SOMEWHERE ELSE"
Really this journal was to state to anyone who cares that I may be leaving and explaining my reasons why. Which really the only reason i feel the need to do that is being vague has it's consequences xD
that photo was also to help people find me at a convention xD
and like I said I couldn't stay here for emotional health reasons if the ads stayed anyways.
I'm pretty much waiting it out a week or so. If it doesnt change I'm afraid I wont be able to stay. :/
And people are typically respectful of it x)
I typically like y audience. You guys are really awesome! Just another reason why the fact that I might actually leave makes me really sad :<