Commission Experiment Update
8 years ago
Well that experiment was insane. I thought an open list would help me with a long term plan but I was wrong. Hahaha. 100 people, many of which it took me so long to get to that by the time I noted them they'd forgotten they commented at all. So that appears to not be the way to do it.
So effective now, the list is suspended and I'll be moving forward with a different method. Apologies to those who were on the list and did want something still, but half of my work at this point has become noting people and that's not great. Instead I'll be doing stream commissions when I have time for the next while. I'll attempt to give preferential treatment to people who were on the old list.
I stream Tuesday, Thursday, Sunday, and occasionally Saturday. I'll update this if my schedule changes.
So effective now, the list is suspended and I'll be moving forward with a different method. Apologies to those who were on the list and did want something still, but half of my work at this point has become noting people and that's not great. Instead I'll be doing stream commissions when I have time for the next while. I'll attempt to give preferential treatment to people who were on the old list.
I stream Tuesday, Thursday, Sunday, and occasionally Saturday. I'll update this if my schedule changes.
Also, I just checked the google drive commission price guide, it shows your, I assume, real name and photo thumbnail. May want to change the profile or set up a separate account or something if you weren't aware and are uncomfortable with this.
The last bit is optional, but if you're going to do capitalism you might as well do it all the way.
I'm sorry to pull this rant here, but I feel super strongly about this. I fight really hard against the idea that art is luxury and that people need to pay for it. I'd always rather the reason you can't get art from me be that there's a queue, rather than you can't afford it. I know that's a super unpopular opinion, but I feel it's right in my heart of hearts.
There are a couple of counter-points I could make, though. I figure you may not be too interested in discussing the economics of furry porn though, so let me know if you'd rather not!
In a sense, this is a fairer system, because if you charged your equilibrium price it would be too much for some people to afford. The low prices with a waiting list make it possible for more people to afford, but there are other problems here, most notably that a lot of people just get on the list and then kinda forget about it. In a world where every artist undercharged and operated waitlists, what would happen is the people who ended up getting art would just be the jerks who signed up to every list indiscriminately. In other words, this system doesn't really favour the poorer commissioners, just the pushier ones. Also all the artists would be very underpaid : )
The streaming solution is better - as well as reducing paperwork for you, it also means that people have to put in a little time and effort to get your commissions, so hopefully you filter for people who really like your stuff. But that said, you still have more demand than supply, so you're just doing another kind of filtering here, for people who are free at the right times to watch an art stream. Also, you're still being underpaid! (Though maybe the convenience of not managing queues and getting rapid feedback in the stream is worth it)
I don't think you should ditch streaming if you like it, but what you might consider, though, is "market segmentation". You could, for example, offer some fast turnaround slots at full equilibrium price, or auction slots or YCHs. This will let you make more money from the commissioners who are willing to pay for convenience or priority jobs, while you can keep cheaper stream slots that are priced more accessibly for when you want to just do some drawing without lots of back-and-forth notes.
I do think not wanting to deny people a chance to get commissions because of affordability is really sweet, but remember you have to live too, and most people in other jobs have no qualms about demanding what they're worth!
I'm definitely not being underpaid. It's the opposite. I think I have nearly the best funded Patreon in the entire furry community. That's not even an exaggeration. I'm incredibly blessed, and while my actual commission prices make it much less profitable to do than Patreon, I still like doing them.
I think I would rather have the pushier fans end up winning out than the rich ones. Neither system is perfect, but if I put myself in the shoes of the commissioner, I would be much more upset if I simply couldn't afford a commission than if I felt like I just hadn't asked enough.
Letting demand drive prices is how MilesDF's prices got so out of control. Reading the comments in his YCH posts are cancer. He's not exactly a humble fellow and you can see the kind of resentment that builds up from setting your prices that astronomically high.
YCHs that I would draw for practice anyway would be a great addition to my arsenal too, but I've just yet to do one.