You've got a versatile character that could handle both aspects, in my opinion. However, I'd be curious to see what a more solid muscle Al would look like. You've seen one side, now see the other. Experiment with it, at least to see if it catches yer fancy. :]

I agree with Chark. There's been a good number of pics of you as a bit of a chub. I wouldn't mind seeing Al with a good six-pack. And, at the same time, it is your character, so it's all on how you feel about the body type. Either way, will still like the way you look, I guarantee it. LOL

Round belly, defined pecs, big arms.

*Luvs Bro HOWEVER he looks* <3333333

Rouuund!

Musclegut with good ab definition is always sexy. But hehey, maybe you'd look good with big arms and a good Y-shaped upper body.

I have nothing to add to prior replies, except maybe to sy that I see both possibilities going equally well.