Resigning from FA staff
8 years ago
🙐✿🙖
As of today, I am no longer on Fur Affinity staff. Resigning from my position wasn't an easy decision, and I will miss working with the awesome team running this show, but if there is one truth in life, it is that sometimes you have to look after yourself first. And sometimes, standing up for what you believe in will hurt. It is certainly true for me, now. I was originally going to step down in about a month and a half, but outside factors came into play that accelerated those plans.
I have left staff on good terms, and if circumstances change in the future, far as I'm concerned I'm open to the idea of rejoining the team. There were multiple factors playing into this decision, and I'm not going to be able to go into detail on all of them due to NDA and/or site policy, but the quick run-down is this:
# As of 27 January 2018, I would have donated five years of my life to Fur Affinity. That's a long time to be volunteering for the primary reward of a job well done. I don't regret the time I've spent, but I have to recognize that it's a significant portion of my life and it may be time to move on for that reason alone.
# Some aspects of internal policy go against my grain, and I am not comfortable standing for those decisions. I have good reasons for my position, others have good reasons for theirs, the two are simply irreconcilable and no available compromise would alleviate my concerns sufficiently for me to feel okay about this.
# I have had significant amounts of venom aimed at me both on Fur Affinity itself and on social media. It's taken the form of malicious rumors, smear campaigns, misrepresentation, and petty potshots at my identity, such as deliberate misgendering. At times, this has risen to levels where my partners have expressed concern for my safety. While I am aware that the people spreading this vitriol are a small subset of Fur Affinity's userbase, it's the absolutely ugliest side of this job, and when it starts affecting my loved ones, it's crossed yet one more line.
# Similar to the above, it is starting to strain my patience to the breaking point to see users and former users (some the same as above, some different) who malign staff in general, or particular colleagues, over administrative action or just because hating on Fur Affinity staff is the cool thing to do this week. This is something that has brought me to the verge of quitting not once, not twice, but three times over my time as staff, and something I hope a future generation of furries will have better manners than to perpetuate.
# Yet another aspect of the above, there is a small but vocal subset of users (and some people who don't even use FA) who feel that the correct response to disagreeing with site rules, site staff, or administrative action, is to launch a fully-fledged shitstorm on social media. This is a persistent pattern that has been in play pretty much as long as I've been on staff (and likely longer), but it's grown increasingly toxic over the last year or so. Subjecting Dragoneer, Fur Affinity, and FA staff to trial by social media every time you don't get your way is bully tactics at their lowest, and I don't have the power to change this. Make no mistake, however, that the people who engage in this are being bullies, and evidently have no qualms about twisting the truth or outright lying in their virtue signaling.
# I may not be able to legally volunteer the amount of time required to perform Fur Affinity staff duties, should I be granted disability status, due to the way Swedish disability pay is structured. It's pretty ridiculous, given that the conditions that make Fur Affinity moderation a task I can perform are not conditions I can reasonably expect to find in a workplace, but it's still a concern I have to take into account.
A huge thank you to my colleagues of these past five years. I've come to value all of you, and I will miss working with you dearly. Also thank you to the users who've been courteous in your interactions with staff - the positive reactions and the people who're willing to own their mistakes and better themselves are the absolute best side of the job, and all that has kept me going at times.
I volunteered for five years because I wanted to help. I wanted to take part in improving communication and holding people to the rules they agreed to when they joined the site. I like to think I have done that at least in some small way.
So long, and thanks for all the fish.
For a follow-up, see this journal where I discuss the emotional impact of both my resignation and the way I was treated on social media
I have left staff on good terms, and if circumstances change in the future, far as I'm concerned I'm open to the idea of rejoining the team. There were multiple factors playing into this decision, and I'm not going to be able to go into detail on all of them due to NDA and/or site policy, but the quick run-down is this:
# As of 27 January 2018, I would have donated five years of my life to Fur Affinity. That's a long time to be volunteering for the primary reward of a job well done. I don't regret the time I've spent, but I have to recognize that it's a significant portion of my life and it may be time to move on for that reason alone.
# Some aspects of internal policy go against my grain, and I am not comfortable standing for those decisions. I have good reasons for my position, others have good reasons for theirs, the two are simply irreconcilable and no available compromise would alleviate my concerns sufficiently for me to feel okay about this.
# I have had significant amounts of venom aimed at me both on Fur Affinity itself and on social media. It's taken the form of malicious rumors, smear campaigns, misrepresentation, and petty potshots at my identity, such as deliberate misgendering. At times, this has risen to levels where my partners have expressed concern for my safety. While I am aware that the people spreading this vitriol are a small subset of Fur Affinity's userbase, it's the absolutely ugliest side of this job, and when it starts affecting my loved ones, it's crossed yet one more line.
# Similar to the above, it is starting to strain my patience to the breaking point to see users and former users (some the same as above, some different) who malign staff in general, or particular colleagues, over administrative action or just because hating on Fur Affinity staff is the cool thing to do this week. This is something that has brought me to the verge of quitting not once, not twice, but three times over my time as staff, and something I hope a future generation of furries will have better manners than to perpetuate.
# Yet another aspect of the above, there is a small but vocal subset of users (and some people who don't even use FA) who feel that the correct response to disagreeing with site rules, site staff, or administrative action, is to launch a fully-fledged shitstorm on social media. This is a persistent pattern that has been in play pretty much as long as I've been on staff (and likely longer), but it's grown increasingly toxic over the last year or so. Subjecting Dragoneer, Fur Affinity, and FA staff to trial by social media every time you don't get your way is bully tactics at their lowest, and I don't have the power to change this. Make no mistake, however, that the people who engage in this are being bullies, and evidently have no qualms about twisting the truth or outright lying in their virtue signaling.
# I may not be able to legally volunteer the amount of time required to perform Fur Affinity staff duties, should I be granted disability status, due to the way Swedish disability pay is structured. It's pretty ridiculous, given that the conditions that make Fur Affinity moderation a task I can perform are not conditions I can reasonably expect to find in a workplace, but it's still a concern I have to take into account.
A huge thank you to my colleagues of these past five years. I've come to value all of you, and I will miss working with you dearly. Also thank you to the users who've been courteous in your interactions with staff - the positive reactions and the people who're willing to own their mistakes and better themselves are the absolute best side of the job, and all that has kept me going at times.
I volunteered for five years because I wanted to help. I wanted to take part in improving communication and holding people to the rules they agreed to when they joined the site. I like to think I have done that at least in some small way.
So long, and thanks for all the fish.
For a follow-up, see this journal where I discuss the emotional impact of both my resignation and the way I was treated on social media
I know and you know and most people with a lick of sense know that if you have to lie in order to make your argument, your argument is barely even a cardboard cut-out.
As a former admin myself, the offer of "death by steak and alcohol poisoning, should you be in the Toronto, ON area" stands. Note me up if you're back my side of the pond and make sure you and your mate's wills are up to date.
Does this mean we'll get to see more of your art, comics and stories in the coming years?
I am indeed hoping to more reliably draw and write after this, though I also have to do some serious healing, mental health wise.
Thank you for the well wishes.
Go frolic with the dolphins!
Do dolphin-frolickers get to pet the fishies?
Anyways, if you have Skype or an IB account, let me know via PM. :)
You seemed to attempt to make/take the least partisan positions possible.
But, you were also seemingly, the only one singled out and blamed for everything under the sun.
Good luck, hope that this decision works out well for you.
Wishing all the best indeed.
I know we're not on the same page about a lot of issues, but I appreciate the well wishes.
But it doesn't ever mean I would wish harm on someone or harass them horribly.
It does seem that... things are a little slanted, at the moment, politically. That if you are not with us you are against us, kind of deal.
Which is frustrating.
Very sorry to read about what had happened to you regarding the stream of abuse. Truly hope that you have managed to calm down from it all a bit, and that you are feeling better now.
Husband and boyfriend have been great support through it. I'll stabilize, little by little.
For now I'm trying to get through things one day at a time, with the support of my partners. It'll take a while for me to rebuild my faith in humanity.
I saw a small portion of the hate directed to you over the years. It's not easy to moderate a site like FA - let alone one the size of FA - and I doubt many of those criticizing you would have been able to do a better job - even if they were able (and willing) to spare the time it requires.
For five years, you've put personal projects on hold for the good of the community. You don't get the option to avoid certain content or people because looking at it and interacting with them is part of the job. And few care about the person behind such interactions, even if you try to be nice.
Over time, it can start to feel like such people make up most of the site; and it gets to the point where you don't even want to visit because you know there'll be a pile of tickets waiting for you with the worst of the fandom. And the only people you can share it all with are in the same boat.
Hopefully you can now take a well-deserved break, reflect on the brighter moments, and decide what you want to do with your copious free time.
In fairness, I don't know any furry art sites that are officially organized as non-profits; they just don't tend to make a profit, most years. IB only costs ~$10/day and still barely breaks even with its donations. I doubt FA does, as a business unit. It seems like more of a thing for IMVU to say "hey, we're using our money usefully somehow."
Trying to convert former volunteers into employees or contractors beyond paying for reasonable expenses also tends to be problematic, in part because you usually can't pay them enough to cover the standard rate for the kind of work they do for free, especially if it's technical. But it also takes the fun out of it, and makes people value their contribution in terms of the money rather than their passion to help the community.
But this is getting a little off-topic, so...
I've enjoyed helping people, and I've enjoyed the camraderie with the rest of staff. I've been able to help answer questions about newsposts, which was something I found a bit lacking in my early days on FA. I've had something meaningful to do, in bite-sized pieces, with my limited energy.
Something changed some time before the US elections, I think mostly after the primaries. The social climate got harsher, and polarization skyrocketed. Being nice isn't enough, if you're not with "us" you're against "us", no matter which "us" is being spoken about. Not a good time to be a socialist hippie who just wants everyone to get along.
One of the things that, to not mince words, broke me, was seeing how easy it apparently was for the people participating in this latest smear campaign to believe the awful things being claimed about me. That was, to me, watching doors being slammed in my face, far as my social life was concerned.
Right now I more than anything feel at loose ends, but I'll find direction again in time.
You have to build up a shell to be staff, let alone in a leadership position. I've had plenty of slings and arrows thrown my way over the years: from the whole fd_2 thing (still proud of getting banned for being TOO REAL ;-p), through the fake pizza orders and getting thrown out of MUCKs and old staff positions over the drama, up to and including people trying to get me fired at work. It was good training for what was to come.
But I have to agree with you: the U.S. elections were a turning point. Suddenly it got OK to publicly throw civility out the window and get downright nasty to people, en masse. No sense of being in a shared community and disagreeing but with a sense of "live and let live". It's all about the issues; and there's no room to stand somewhere in the middle, or off to the side. The increased youth of the fandom nowadays probably doesn't help - just makes the emotion more raw.
As for breaking, I always kept this picture in mind; it's a fairly accurate reflection of the situation. The mightiest waves will break on the rocks - but it's not always easy to be a rock, and they can still wear away the foundation over the years, if it's not regularly replenished. Just remember why they're saying all this, and trying to get to you: they're in no position to do anything directly. Where action is hard or impossible, words are cheap.
Social-wise, it's all too easy to second-guess yourself and say "everyone is thinking bad things about me" after this kind of campaign. Bear in mind the saying that "you'd care less about what people thought about you if you knew how little they did". Yeah, there's a news story, and the tweets; but the blunt reality is that 98% of furries won't see any of it - and of the other 2%, most won't even remember your name a week on.
When it comes to reality, I've seen one instance of a person being nasty to me at FC, right after the fd_2 stuff. That's about it. You can say "maybe they had the drama in mind while talking with me", but maybe they didn't, or they secretly disapproved of it; in any case, it doesn't do to dwell on it, because it won't help you move on.
So go to that furmeet. Grab your friends and make a day trip to your local con. Stick around in that forum/MUCK/whatever. Don't let it get you down and withdraw from life. After all, in all likelihood most of those slinging mud probably never thought or cared about you personally - just what they thought you represented.
Some types of criticism, I'm very well equipped to shrug off. Others... not so much. I'm sure to some people that comes across as "it hits home because it's on the mark", but that's on them. My Achilles heel, in some ways, is that my comprehension of malice is limited - it's just profoundly alien to me why people would do this. Particularly those individuals who have gone so far as to say things they must know to be untrue (claiming I said things in exchanges that never happened, for instance), seemingly in order to have their own story of horrible misdeeds I supposedly committed. It's some kind of twisted one-upmanship that I just cannot wrap my head around (I also almost completely lack competitive spirit), and that distresses me. There is this... thing... being passed around, and having stuff added to it, like a really disgusting katamari of libel, and I'm watching it grow out of control.
If people want to be mad about calls I've made, that's fine. I can understand that, it makes sense, if nothing else so because being told they're wrong in some way can bruise someone's ego. I'm sorry my actions upset them, but rules are rules. I can't be sorry about "being a nazi", any more than I can be sorry about being, I don't know, a tax collector, or a tyrannosaurus rex. Because I am none of those.
After all, in all likelihood most of those slinging mud probably never thought or cared about you personally - just what they thought you represented.
This is exactly why I've tried to be open about the impact their (collective) actions had on me. While it may not sway everyone, if I can get a few people to stop and think "Hey, what might this do to the person?" that would be a good thing wrought from the whole hellish mess.
This statement is too vague. :/
My personal beliefs have nothing to do with any action I've taken as staff. My role as staff has strictly been to enforce the rules - if you think the rule should be something it is not, that is not my fault, and I would appreciate it if you would refrain from giving me grief over it.
I have no fucking idea what you think you've gleaned from my "comments", but if it indicates "right-wing" you're not just off base but losing the ball game.
Now kindly show me the courtesy of taking your preconceived notions out of my space.
I'm not sure what accountability you'd be looking for beyond "Hey you made this decision I'm overruling you because X", to be honest. Either way, I'm a bit baffled as to why you'd see the need to show up to say this more than five months after the fact.
I don't often comment publicly regarding admins, even if good, so as not to be seen as currying favor, but as far as I could see with my own experience, you always replied nicely to my tickets, and would explain why / why not something was / wasn't. With the current anonymity (understandably so), we won't know which admins to thank later on. So thank you for all you did for us, me, and FA.